Minutes of the July 10, 2005 meeting
[Note: These submissions appear on the
Dec 05 LoAR]
Meeting commenced at 11:00 AM.
In attendance were: Lachlan Crescent, Su Dolphin, Balthasar
Seraph, Martin (Al Sahid), Douglas Flame, Hrorek
Chevron, Catherine de Winter, Vivienne Recorder, Rotheric
Kynith, Jeanne Marie Wreath, Elsbeth Nanny.
The schedule for the rest of the year: August 7th, September 11th, October
2nd, November 6th, and December 4th.
The CoH is discarding the broken copiers, if anyone wants to try to resurrect
them, they may take them away.
Crescent, and the College (especially the typists) appreciate everyone's
efforts to send submission summaries prior to the meeting. The earlier you send
them in, the easier it will be for Crescent, and the more time can be saved in
the meeting. Please send them as early as you can, with a deadline of the
evening Thursday before the meeting. Submissions received
after Thursday but before 10AM on the day of the meeting may still be
considered at that meeting at the end of the meeting. If a meeting is running
too long, Crescent reserves the right to end the meeting, pending all remaining
decisions until the next meeting.
Submission summaries should include all of the info on the form - Name,
Blazon, checked boxes, resubmission or new submission, name documentation. See
current minutes for the information that we need and the format we'd prefer.
Please send them to
Vivienne de Lemperiere has volunteered to type all letters of acceptance and
returns to submitters after we hear from Laurel. For this staff position, she
will use the staff heraldic title, Recorder.
Next year's KWHS will be in New Orleans on July 16-18, 2006. Crescent has
indicated that he wishes to put together a team to bid for the 2007 KWHS.
Approved submissions will be forwarded to Laurel on the August 25, 2005
Letter of Intent
al-Sahid, Shire of
al-Sahid, Shire of. Change of designator from al-Sahid, Canton of.
[Name] This name was registered 08/87, as al-Sahid, Canton of. At some point,
they became a Shire in the Kingdom of Caid. Now the shire would like the
reference in the armorial to match their current status.
Change approved and forwarded to Laurel.
Caid, Kingdom of
Iain Edwardson. New name and device. Vert, a fireball
proper within a bordure rayonny Or.
[Name] The submitter is interested in a masculine name; no other boxes are
"... the name Iain, while ruled SCA compatible, is not attested
in period. [Iain Bán Menzies, 07/00, R-Atlantia]"
Also, "Ian was ruled SCA-compatible in April of 1997. [Ian
Duncanson, 09/01, A-Caid]". We found Iain in Black, page
372, undated, as a newer form of Eoin. In addition, OCM, page 88,
lists Eoin, Ioan, and Eoan are listed as forms common in the
13th C. All of these various spellings are likely pronounced essentially the
same as the modern "Ian".
Edwardson is found in R&W (s.n. Edwardson, p. 152) where
William Edwardson is dated to 1518.
As submitted, this name is two steps from period practice, and thus is
unregisterable. The first step is the use of an SCA-compatible name element,
and the other for lingual mix (Gaelic/English).
[Ian Griffen the Archer] Submitted as Iain Griffen the Archer,
Iain is a Gaelic spelling of which cannot be combined with an English
name. We have substituted the Anglicized spelling, Ian. (Jaelle of Armida, LoAR
February 1998, p. 2)
We considered changing the given name to Ian. As this is the
Anglicized form of the name, the resulting name is only a single step from
period practice. We also discussed changing the name to one of the documented
examples above. This would remove the SCA-compatible name, but would result in
a spelling which might be undesirable to the submitter. As we must return the
device (see below), we are going to give the submitter the chance to make their
own choice on which name they prefer.
We note that this is clear of John Edward (09/94).
[Device] This device is being returned for lack of contrast (RfS VIII.2), as
it has a black charge on a vert field. A black charge proper is treated as
sable for application of the rule of tincture. Options include swapping the
bordure and field colors; changing the fireball to Or or argent.
Name returned for consultation with the submitter. Device returned
for lack of contrast.
Heatherwyne, Shire of
Davin Mac Alister of Drake's Height. New device change.
Azure, two natural tigers couchant addorsed agent striped sable and a
dragon couchant bendwise sinister argent.
[Name] The submitter's name was registered 07/90.
[Device] His current device (registered 01/01), Per chevron azure and Or,
two natural tigers couchant addorsed tails entwined argent marked and a bird
volant wings displayed sable, is to be released upon registration of this
We note that the submitter's intention was to have a "striking"
dragon but we felt that the submitted blazon more closely describes the
depiction. We invite the College's comments and suggestions.
approved and forwarded to Laurel withdrawn by
Starkhafn, Barony of
Illaria de Farnedon. New name.
[Name] The submitter is interested in a feminine name from the 11th-13th
centuries but has not marked the box requesting authenticity. She will accept
minor but not major changes, and if the name must be changed she cares most
about the sound.
Illaria is found in Reaney and Wilson, 3rd edition (s.n.
Hillary, p. 232) where it is dated to 1219.
de Farnedon is found in Reaney and Wilson, 3rd edition,
(s.n. Farndon, p. 163) dated to 1248.
Name approved and forwarded to Laurel.
Ishikawa Akirakeiko. Laurel resub. device. Sable, a demi
sun argent and a ford proper.
[Name] The submitter's name was registered 09/02.
[Armory] Her previous submission, Argent, in pale a demi-sun and a
Japanese stream sable, was returned by Laurel 02/03 as a Japanese stream
cannot be blazoned in European heraldic terms. A resubmission was returned by
Crescent 04/05 for lack of payment (resubmission timing exceeded Caid's
definition of "timely" to one year following return). This design
uses only European style charges and a new submission payment was received.
Device approved and forwarded to Laurel.
Mairghread ingean Toirdhealblaigh. New Device. Or, a
Celtic cross vert and on a chief azure three mullets argent.
[Name] The submitter's name was registered 02/03.
[Device] We recommend that the submitter should not draw the Celtic cross
touching the edge of the field.
Device approved and forwarded to Laurel.
Meadhbh inghean Shéamus (Lia da Firenze). New device.
Azure semi of musical notes and on a fess argent a triquetra
[Name] The submitter's name Meadhbh inghean Shéamus, was
returned for conflict by Laurel 03/05. The first name submitted, Lia da
Firenze was forwarded to Laurel 08/04, withdrawn by the submitter and
manually indicated on the LoI, but registered in error by Laurel 01/05. This
should be corrected via errata by Laurel in the near future. [Armory] The
device was conflict checked and found free of conflict. Unfortunately, we must
return this at this time for lack of registered name.
PLEASE NOTE - We considered forwarding this armory under Lia da
Firenze, but determined that the registration was in error since it was
withdrawn by submitter prior to registration.
Device returned for lack of a registered name.
Mina de Valencia y Alcaçar. Kingdom resub device.
Gules, a tierce argent.
[Name] The submitter's name appears on Caid's 06/24/05 LoI.
[Armory] Her previous device, Gules, a tierce counterermine, was
returned 04/05 by Crescent for lack of contrast. This problem has been
Unfortunately, this armory conflicts with the arms of Bahrain, Gules, a
dexter tierce indented argent.
Device returned for conflict.
Tomás mac Caoil - Kingdom resub device: Per bend
sinister wavy azure and argent, in annulo a lizard argent and a lizard azure
all within an annulet counterchanged.
[Name] Name registered 08/01.
[Armory] His previous submission, Per bend sinister wavy azure and
argent, two lizards in annulo bendwise within an annulet counterchanged,
was returned by Crescent 11/04 for redraw. The difficulties of this earlier
design have been fixed.
Device approved and forwarded to Laurel.
Order of Precedence Notes
Ó Corráin, Donnchadh, and Maguire, Fidelma. Irish Names.
Dublin: The Lilliput Press, 1990. [OCM]
Reaney, P. H., and Wilson, R. M. A Dictionary of English Surnames
Oxford: Oxford Uni. Press, 3rd ed. 1995. [R&W]
Return to the Minutes list
Return to the main Herald's page
Return to the Caid home page